(09-19-2023, 08:54 AM)Mikey Wrote: I wish PFF would give some weight to playing time. There's no way anyone is going to say of Ernest was our best player yesterday. Did he not screw up when his number was called? Sure, we can all grant that, but there's no way anyone should think he'd keep up that level of performance if he got the same number of snaps as Etienne.

I think they put too much weight on a bad play, especially when considering the volume of plays some of the guys have.

I guess I'll stick to the eye test.

Their grading has always been wacky in certain ways.

It doesn't take much to skew a game grade, and they choose not to compute factors that should be included in their equation. 

One bad play can affect a grade too much as can one good one. 

They don't seem to penalize offensive linemen for being bullrushed back onto the toes of their quarterback either which I find puzzling. 

Eye test is still best - and that all22 replay reveals lots of stuff we tend to miss.

---