(09-27-2023, 11:27 PM)OG-JAGFAN Wrote:

(09-27-2023, 03:28 PM)JagsFanSince95 Wrote: Yes and no. He isn't terrible, but he is also not playing very well. What I see on the film isn't exactly what I would call "cook" tier. He's definitely doing some good things but overall body of work is pretty mid. Remember, if we are to take this QB as a top tier, elite level QB this is the standard I am grading off of. He is not playing well if you consider him a top 5 QB in this league, he just isn't.

Really, can I see your film break down. 

Here is one showing he played well against the Texans 

https://youtu.be/ceRzH6NTcg4?si=9uP7fHwgvBQGt-AG

No one is arguing if Trevor knows how to play QB... I am only stating if we want to crown the guy, he needs to play better. You think this tape breakdown is a display of elite QB play? Y I K E S. The 1st/3rd play is a drop, 2nd play is an bad mechanics/late throw/wrong drop pick whatever you think it is(Likely poor footwork/drop) its the SAME PROBLEM he had in KC throwing uncatchable balls in the end zone, only 1 of the 3 toe tappers were even close to completions and Zay was in fact lazy there and should have scored. He also whiffed on a wide open Zay as well, 3 stinkers in the red area. I have no bias against the guy, he is a good QB...  BUT, if you can sit here with a straight face and say Trevor is playing elite/top 5 QB football... We aren't looking at the same QB.

---