So basically the question is:


Which situation would you prefer:

 

For a numbers game:

Chad Henne Hypothetical 2014 season: 3456 yards 16 TD's 17 INTs

Hypothetical QB 2014 season: 3680 yards, 20 TD's, 14 INT's


Situation A:

Jags take the QB and upgrade their QB situation, but might not have The Answer.  The QB will be serviceable, but may not ever be able to make a deep playoff run

 

Situation B:

Jags pass on the QB, and instead get a more talented player at a different position


In which case, personally I'd prefer Situation A.  Though Situation B could lead to a better team overall in the long run.  Though that's not a certainty.  

---