Quote:Long time follower of the board here. I don't post much but will at different times of the year cause my life will allow it lol.


The reason I asked this question is because I see way too much importance on the qb position on this tread. I want to start a healthy debate with quality answers as to why one way is better than the other


Obviously we've seen both succeed but some seem to push one more than the other. I want to know what is it that makes one more prolific than the other


I intend to play devil advocate and play both side but just want to get an idea on what everyone thinks.

 

The pick a QB just because you need one approach is for fanboys and GMs who run their teams like fanboys. Look at Idzik's Jets. Geno Smith was the "top" QB available in a dreadful class. He's now competing with a washed-up Michael Vick. I say keep building until you find a QB worth drafting. If not, take flyers on lower-round QBs, like a team would do for a LB, until the right fit comes along. It worked for the Eagles/Nick Foles and the Seahawks/Russell Wilson, and it could work for the Jags. 

---