Quote:You liked Geno Smith and you like Birdgewater? Lol. I will stop following this team is we blow our first round pick on Bustwater. It's clear as day that this guy can't play in this league. Crappy college competition. Noodle arm. Built like a 12 year old. Tyrod Taylor, Tavares Jackson, Josh Johnson clone. And those guys had arms at least.

Lol I know right. I do think those guys can play but they need to be in solid situations. I mainly said that to say qb is a hard position to evaluate. A guy like Brady Quinn has the tools but can't put it together, Russell Wilson doesn't fit the mold but can play. Some guys need to sit (Kaep) some guys can play from day one (Luck).


The thing I'm realizing is that it is a situation thing for about 90% of the qbs playing and that's the insight we should be using when talking about qb. Had the Browns had the first pick in 99 would Manning have dominated in Clevland, if we drafted Brady would he have been out of the league in 3 years?

---