Interesting debate. I think you will build the roster first. If the Jags are not 100% commited to one of the top 3 QB's, they should draft someone else. You can't miss on No. 3 pick. It's also good to have at least a solid OL, if you want to get a rookie, potentially franchise QB behind there. As I've read here, you still have some holes on the OL. I was very worried about Wilson's health behind our OL last year. It's true we had injuries, but still pass protection was bad most of the times.

 

 

Quote:The pick a QB just because you need one approach is for fanboys and GMs who run their teams like fanboys. Look at Idzik's Jets. Geno Smith was the "top" QB available in a dreadful class. He's now competing with a washed-up Michael Vick. I say keep building until you find a QB worth drafting. If not, take flyers on lower-round QBs, like a team would do for a LB, until the right fit comes along. It worked for the Eagles/Nick Foles and the Seahawks/Russell Wilson, and it could work for the Jags. 

 

To be fair, they drafted Geno in 2nd round, even though they had 2 first round picks they both used on defense. I don't think they are longterm commited to Geno, if he doesn't work out now that they get him some weapons (Decker and probably another 1st or 2nd round WR in this deep WR class). Geno will get a year or two to prove, he can be a good QB, if not, they will move on. I know Vick could be the starter week 1, but I doubt he'll remain healthy more than 3-4 games, so Geno will get his chance again. 

 

If any QB was "overdrafted" last year, it was E.J. Manuel.

---