(11-14-2024, 08:30 AM)flgatorsandjags Wrote:

(11-13-2024, 12:52 PM)We Mikey Wrote: WITHOUT HINDSIGHT YOU DON'T KNOW THAT. THAT IS THE TEXTBOOK DEFINITION OF HINDSIGHT. 

It's like arguing with a rutabaga.

So the guy with 1600 scrimmage yards and 15TD was less an impact player than the guy with 1370 and 10. Amazing.

Williams was a one trick pony in college and he’s still a one trick pony in the NFL, I mentioned that plenty of times in the pre draft process .  Your first problem is just looking at stats when eventuating talent coming into the NFL. You keep saying hindsight like Gibbs is a better player and would be the better pick.   So if both were coming out now in hindsight Gibbs would be the better pick?

I stand by my statement. Arguing with a rutabaga.

If you cannot see why the statement "If Jameson Williams and Jamyj Gibbs came out in the same draft you would take Williams.  Thats what you call stupid" is only valid with the benefit of hindsight, I fear there is too much to explain about need, positional value, or even statistics to clarify the issue.

---