FBT...I am not sure I have seen Henne look good...his best game as a Jag was the Texans game where Blackmon exploded two years ago...but IMO that was ALL Blackmon...he turned short throws into 60+ yard TDs...

 

I do agree that both have bad decision making at times...but at least you got positive TD to INT ratios most years with David and he could run when needed...Henne is more likely to give you more INTs/TOs than TDs on a yearly basis...and add in bone headed mistakes...which in my mind why he is behind David.

 

Of course arguing who is better Garrard or Henne is like seeing who the tallest midget is really...at the end of the day who cares the both come up short.

---