Elliot Harrison asked this question about all 32 teams, divided by conference. Here is our part of the AFC article:

 

 

<p style="font-family:arial, verdana, helvetica;color:rgb(34,34,33);"><b>JACKSONVILLE <a>JAGUARS</a>: Jimmy Smith, wide receiver</b>

<p style="font-family:arial, verdana, helvetica;color:rgb(34,34,33);">Tough call, here. Tony Boselli was dominant, but he didn't play long enough. Keenan McCardell was a model of consistency, but he was never truly dominant. Fred Taylor's 11,271 rushing yards for the franchise, meanwhile, are tough to dismiss. Yet, with apologies to Taylor and Maurice Jones-Drew, Smith's résumé is simply impossible to ignore. Former Eagles coach Rich Kotite once told the guy he would never make it in the NFL. Smith responded by racking up nine -- NINE!! -- 1,000-yard seasons in Jacksonville. With 862 receptions to his name, Smith's easily the most prolific pass-catcher in Jags history.

<p style="font-family:arial, verdana, helvetica;color:rgb(34,34,33);"> 

<p style="font-family:arial, verdana, helvetica;color:rgb(34,34,33);">I hate the crap about Tony Boselli not playing long enough. He retired early because of injuries, not performance, so I don't think it should be counted against him. But to call him better than both Jimmy Smith and Fred Taylor would be hard because there are few statistics for left tackles. I agree it is a tough call among those three.

<p style="font-family:arial, verdana, helvetica;color:rgb(34,34,33);"> 

<p style="font-family:arial, verdana, helvetica;color:rgb(34,34,33);">Do you agree or disagree with Harrison?

---