Quote:Of course.  If any QB is ruined you can just claim the QB didn't have the mythical "it" and call it a day, and then the other side is left trying to prove a negative.     It's a pretty common tactic.  

 

And I think Newton is a pretty classic case of a QB who has hit a ceiling and will never achieve a higher level until he revamps his mechanics to become a much more accurate QB.  He's still the same exact guy who came into the league 3 years ago.     Basically the same comp% and same passer rating in Year 3 that he had as a rookie.  It's a shame.   He could have been so much more than this.