To answer the question depends on what you are looking for.

 

My first thought is Jimmy Smith.  He was one of the most feared wide receivers in the game, and just "did it" every time that he was on the field.  I loved watching him play and meeting/talking with him personally was a wonderful thing.  His rise to stardom is also a very good story.

 

Fred Taylor comes to mind.  He had to go through the "fragile freddy" times and still worked his way up to be one of the best running backs of all time (looking at stats).

 

I have to go with Jimmy Smith to answer this question, but along with Fred Taylor other considerations are Mark Brunell and Tony Boselli.

---