It sure does seem like the longer Garrard has been gone the better he was when he was here. He had the one good year capped off with a road playoff win against the hated Steelers. Other then that he was pretty average with the occasional flash of being above average. Heck, even Henne has shown brief flashes of being above average, although as we all know, it doesn't last very long and rarely ends well.

 

I guess to really settle the Garrard vs Henne debate, you only have to ask yourself 1 question: Which of the 2 would you want to be your starting QB on the current Jags team going into this season?

 

Answer that question and that will tell you who the better average QB is.

 

Personally I would take Garrard b/c I believe he gives you the better chance of winning a game between the 2.

 

I know Henne's play is much more fresh in your minds, but i would still pick DG over Henne if I could only choose between the 2.

 

On a side note, I would pick Henne over Blaine Gabbert, so as you can see I'm not a Henne hater.

---