Going off their first two years in the league they have similar numbers in yards, tds, with Peyton having way more interceptions.


I give Luck the advantage because unlike Manning Luck has 600 yards rushing and 9 TDs where as Manning has 120 yards rushing and 2 tds at this point.


Luck also led a team that was awful to the playoffs in his first year when Manning stayed 3-13


Manning did not get his first playoff win until 2003 his 6th season


Luck did it in his second season


So ya Luck > Manning when comparing their first 2 years fact

but i believe in the long run Luck will be > Manning   Opinion

---