my bias comes from liking the way Luck plays the game.

 

I've never seen Luck ball up in the fetal position when the pocket collapses


I've never seen Manning scoop a fumble and superman dive into the endzone


the reason Eli has more super bowls is because he is willing to risk it all for the win, Manning plays the game like a mathematician plays poker.  No balls


He relies on the sure thing instead of the occasional unexpected and that sure thing caused a pick 6 in his saints superbowl.


Manning has had more rule changes to help him than probably any other player in the history of the game.  He throws a seem pass down the middle of the field and gives Austin Collie a concussion, the very next play he throws the same late arriving pass to Blair White.  He is supposed to be a great team mate.  


8 one and done's in the playoffs (5 of which he had home field advantage).  6 years to get his first playoff win.   A Super Bowl victory run that saw him throw 3 tds and 7 int.


 

---