Quote:First off, that reply was in regard to what I said, which didn't even involve Eli manning.


Second off, Andrew luck was labeled such things as "perfect" or "the best prospect since john elway" etc...


When in his first two years he has played comparable or worse than guys like nick foles or Andy dalton and you colts fans or stooges like TMD bashes a guy like Andy Dalton but praises luck when they have been similar, I'm going to call you out on it.


When you use the argument "luck performed better than Dalton in the playoffs!!!" I'm gonna tell you that mark Sanchez performed way better than luck in the playoffs and just as pedestrian as luck in the regular season and look where he is at now.


I think luck, Dalton, and foles are all top 12 qbs in the NFL. I don't think luck is ever going to be the best. He has room to grow and maybe become top 5, but foles has just a good of chance, and if Dalton can start notching playoff wins and you look at the rest of his body of work then he might be right around 7 or 8. Once p manning, Brady, and Brees are no longer playing, guys like luck, Dalton, foles, cam, hopefully bortles are going to be next in line to be the best in the league.


But luck didn't seem to make big strides from season 1 to season 2. Foles took a huge step forward.


The main point in all the babble is, Andrew luck: he's mediocre right now. Don't get offended because he's your Messiah.

 

You keep saying "you" when I've never said any of that. I've barely been involved in this conversation on this thread.

 

You HAVE to look at the players that around Foles/Dalton/Luck. Luck clearly doesn't have the same supporting cast as those two, especially Dalton and ESPECIALLY in Luck's first year.

 

Also, it's incredibly hilarious that all you use is STATS STATS STATS. Use your eyes. Actually watch the game. Watch the plays. Watch what's happening. It's not coincidence or luck (lower case l) that 90% of people on this planet think Luck is a good/great QB. Only those who have an agenda (ie: YOU) who think otherwise.

---