I'd easily take Dalton, matt Ryan, and cam maybe even tannehill ahead of luck. If this were a redraft. If it was actually just for one season like this upcoming year I would take big Ben and romo as well outside of the top 5 that colts warrior listed.


That puts luck at 11 or 12. Which isn't bad but its not great.


Again, cw, what makes him deserve to be the 6th best guy? His average to below average completion % and QB ranking? His questionable decision making? His mediocre accuracy?


Those are not things that you find in an elite QB. His clutch factor doesn't overcome those things. He has shown no improvement from his first game to this last preseason game.


Yes, he made the playoffs. He does play in the worst division in football so he had an easy road. Yes he's the best QB in the division right now but that doesn't mean crap.


You tell me, with good reasoning why Andrew luck is better than Andy Dalton, cam newton, or even Ryan tannehill who has pretty similar stats and eaaaaaasily has always had less to work with than luck.


If you're going to just go with the "watch them play" argument don't waste your time, because I've watched all of them play plenty and I know all of their stats.


So I ask you, logically, you sell me on why Andrew luck should be considered that good and how am I wrong?

---