In 2012 (the last year when the two threw enough passes to be measured, Football Outsiders' stats had them neck and neck - depending on which of their rating stats you used, they were 32nd and 33rd or 34th and 33rd. By QBR, Gabbert was actually as high as 30th, with Henne a shouldn't-be-starting-in-this-league 34th.
 
This week, they say of Henne:
 

Quote:Henne was sacked 10 times, the most of any quarterback since Greg McElroy for the Jets in 2012. He did not pick up a first down until the Jags were down by 21 points in the second quarter, and only had four first downs on the day. On first and second downs, he went 9-of-20 for 55 yards with one first down, one interception, and four sacks. You know, maybe it wasn't Blaine Gabbert's fault after all.

Really, any discussion of whether Henne is better than Gabbert or Gabbert is better than Henne is entirely moot. You don't want either of them starting at quarterback for you. Ever.

---