Quote:At the same point in their career, Luck has much fewer INT's than Manning did. Actually Luck has had a better start to his career than Manning did.

That is true, but luck just doesn't seem to be improving on it. Which was one of the main points I've been making, he kinda seems like he is what he is. Obviously Peyton Manning progressed to a whole new level.


But more importantly its hard to compare qbs like that. When Peyton started it was a whole different game. The rules are made now so that qbs put up video game numbers every Sunday.


This one is a hard argument to have because we won't really know enough to see if he improved for probably another three years.


I think he is a good player and the colts are better off with him. He just isn't an "elite" guy like everyone has been crowning him without true validation.

---