Quote:Ummm luck has thrown the ball 260 times to RW's 139.


RW has a very strong arm. He's incredibly accurate. Smart. Mobile. Very good passer on the move as well.


I would venture to say that RW has a better arm than luck and throws a nicer ball.


Based on their first years already in the league I'd take Dalton, based on physical ability and a 5 year projection just based on the chance that luck hasn't peaked, I'd take luck.


I also think I just convinced myself that I'd take RW over luck as well.

Yes, Luck has thrown more because that's the team's strength. What does that tell you about RW? Marshawn Lynch is their offensive focus.

 

Let's look at RW's numbers by themselves. Again, he's only thrown for 978 yards in 5 games. He's averaging less than 200 yards per game. Never mind how that compares to Luck's numbers. Is that what you want from the "best young QB" in the league? 

 

Wilson's success so far is fairly easy to define. The Seahawks have one of the best run games in the league, without including RW's rushing stats. He's had the best defense in the league, and they're still a very good defense this year. And their special team's is one of the best.

 

Why have the Colts won so much? 11-5 both of Luck's first 2 years with NO running game, one of the worst O-lines in the league the past two years, and a defense that's ranked in the bottom third the past two year's. Is it because Andrew Luck has contributed significantly to those wins? An easy schedule?--with wins against the Packers, Lions, Chiefs, Texans (AFC South Champs in 2012) Vikings, Forty Niners, Broncos, Seahawks, and Ravens.

---