Quote:It's not an honor for players who are  just very good.  It would cheapen it for the those who really do belong in there.  Personally, I think it should be based on performance (Taylor and Boselli are arguably HOF candidates) and off the field conduct (which is why JSmooth probably shouldn't be there).  Brunell probably shouldn't be in either.  He was a pretty good player in his day but can anyone really make an argument that he's worthy to even be considered for the HOF?  Same for MJD.  Do you really want an honor were you might have 50+ people in it within a few years? 

 

Oh, so now it's only for HOF players? Better take Boselli and Taylor's name down, 'cause they ain't getting in.

 

This is the Jaguars Pride - not the Hall of Fame. For players who had a great impact for the Jaguars. Thus, Brunell is a natural. This has nothing to do with the HOF. And Smith will probably get in once more time passes. If he can stay out of jail.

 

Which is why MJD will get in. Your "you might have 50+ in it in a few years" is a phony argument.

---