Quote:You're going to run into that problem no matter what cut-off you make, whether it be 2, 4, 8, 16, 24, or 32. This is why I'd like to see your list of 16 teams for last season so I can go through and do the same.

 

Just to reiterate this point, because I'm sure neither you or Trav will list your hypothetical 2013 16 team playoff:

 

UCF lost, at home, to a South Carolina team that was missing it's starting QB for most of the game. USC was ranked #8 at the end of the season. They would not be eligible for a 16 team playoff, but UCF would?  You're going to run into these kind of scenarios regardless of the cut-off.

 

The three at large bids would be reserved for teams who had exceptional seasons but didn't win a P5 conference. I mean, I wouldn't be opposed to assuring that 1 at large bid must go to a non-P5 school if you think that makes things more fair.

---