Quote:Yes, I know. which is why Josh's system doesn't make things more "fair" by just allowing more teams.

 

 

I was misunderstanding you to this point. I thought you meant that P5 conference champs +1 at large bid per P5 conference, leaving 6 at large bids for non P-5 schools. You can see why I was asking for your 16 teams under that assumption.

 

If your goal is to crown the best team in college football, then I really can't see putting Louisiana-Lafayette in the playoffs over 11-1 Alabma.

 

Louisiana-Lafayette (9-4) losses to:

Arkansas (who went 0-7 in the SEC)

Kansas St.

UL-Monroe

South Alabama

 

Alabama (11-1) losses to:

#4 Auburn (on the road)

That was perfect. And that is the mentality of the NCAA. It is the power 5 conferences and that is it for the most part. The rest of 1A has little to no chance, and that sucks imo.

 

If the NCAA decided to give everyone a shot then the talent over time would make it to the schools you are listing. Right now there is no shot of that. But if 4 star Billy Football chose to go to La. Lafayette, and 4-5 of his friends do to, then the next year 4-5 more, then the field becomes level. The way it is set up now doesn't even allow for that to happen either. Why have 15 1A conferences and play by separate rules.

 

Again, that's like having a different set of rules for 1-2 divisions in the NFL, just doesn't make sense.

 

Plus, Georgia Southern is the conference leader in the Sun Belt, not La. Lafayette.

---