Quote:I'm not saying BB5 is Henne, but just to play devil's advocate I looked up Henne's stats and compared them to BB5's...

 

They are very similar...  

 

Yes, BB5 is a rookie, yes the O-Line stinks, yes his WRs are rookies.  

 

But it cannot be denied a couple things:

 

1.  BB5's production has decreased now compared to his first 4 games.

 

2.  Henne's 2013 season and BB5's 2014 are similar in terms of YPA, Completion%, and QB rating...

 

Yes, he's a rookie.  Yeah, the O-line stinks, yeah the WRs aren't world beaters and they are rookies...  

 

But you know something that's been constant?  The coaching staff and the offensive philosophy.  

 

But yes, he's a rookie.  The O-Line stinks.  The WRs are rookies...  

My post wasn't directed at you specifically, and I can sum up my issues by pointing out the bolded portion above -- 

 

-- and then reiterating that 4 game samples of rookie QB stats are absolutely meaningless to me.  

 

I think that analyzing bits and pieces of a rookie QBs first season and attributing the failures to an OC is almost as fruitful as using the numbers from your electric bill to play the lottery and expecting a result.  

---