Quote:QB rating-wise and yardage wise, Luck has played better...

 

But Luck has thrown 7 INTs and has 1 lost fumble in 3 playoff games played.  http://espn.go.com/nfl/player/stats/_/id...ndrew-luck

 

 Dalton has turned over the ball as well, but in three games he's turned it over 6 times...  

 

So I guess, at this point I think you have to still say luck has been better in the playoffs.  

 

But...  Dalton right now, in December is having a tremendous statistical performance compared to Luck...  So maybe you take the player that is playing better right now...  In that case, you take Dalton, and you don't look back.

 

http://espn.go.com/nfl/player/splits/_/i...ndy-dalton

 

I guess it's because Luck is in the same division as the Jaguars and thus denigrating Luck will make the Jaguars look better - or something. Sure that's stupid logic, but why else would some posters on here embarrass themselves like this?

 

Do you really think any GM in the NFL would select Dalton over Luck?

 

And does anyone actually watch these games? Does anyone think the Colts are anything other than mediocre? It's a miracle they make the playoffs. They do because today's NFL is geared toward having a very good QB = winning. Which is what the Colts do.

 

If Luck played on the Seahawks I'm sure people would think differently, as then he wouldn't have to practically win games on his own.

---