No one has been able to pad their stats as well as Peyton. He has all of those regular season records, but they mean practically nothing given his failures in the post season. Yes he won a superbowl, but given his regular season numbers, and the supporting cast he's had, especially at Denver I dont see why he should be mentioned in the greatest of all time discussion. He's been very poor for the second half of the season (and obviously the playoffs) as he admitted. I think he'll give it another year but I can see him retiring mid season.

 

Its well known that Peyton has 2 major weaknesses

 

1) Weather

2) Pressure

 

He cant perform in less than ideal weather conditions, and he definitely cant perform under pressure. Hence why he's been 1 and done NINE times in the playoffs.

 

Tom Brady may not have the regular season numbers, but I would take him every time over Peyton. He's a much better, and far more clutch QB and has basically dragged a more often than not, subpar team constantly to AFC Championship and Superbowl games. He's been in 9 AFC championship games, doesnt have a losing record in the regular season to any team in the NFL, has the most playoff wins, and most TDs in playoff history.

 

For me it isnt even a discussion. I know people hate the Patriots and Belichick but I have nothing but respect for Brady.

---