Quote:wins and losses. plus trading away our 1st round lineman then leading the league in QB sacks after.....that just doesn't look good. it cant if you're being honest. I'm not saying ALL the moves are bad but he hasn't EARNED the right to be the guy that we DON'T question. has he? what has Dave done to NOT be questioned in his moves? it's the business....either you win or all your moves look stupid. Chip Kelly will either be a complete idiot or genius because of the moves he made this offseason. thats how it goes

 

No, not yet.

 

Has he made some questionable moves? 

 

Absolutely.  Right now I am at the point of questioning Joeckel, even though I understand the Monroe trade.

 

But understanding the draft is a crapshoot...misses are unavoidable, even among the very best GMs.  Jimmy Jonson drafted Alexander Wright.  Bill Walsh drafted Daniel Stubbs and Terrence Flagler.

 

But saying Caldwell is not beyond questioning is not the same as saying all his moves have been questionable.

---