Quote:The "Watt isn't that good" crew remind me of the "Wilson is better than Luck" group.


Such foolish opinions wouldnt bit muttered if they played in a different division. But, alas, they are in the AFCS so we must pretend like they are overrated.


That being said I actually appreciate a lot of Treestone's arguments here. I'm okay with saying he is dominant but probably not THE best player in the league. Damn close though.

 

The idea that Watt "isn't that good" is absurd, he's obviously a great player at his position. Most of the argument hasn't been over whether he's playing on a hall of fame level, because so far he is, the argument has been over the question of whether a DE can be valuable enough to actually win the MVP award, and so far he hasn't been.

---