well my opinion was pretty much summed up here 


http://jungle.jaguars.com/index.php?/topic/12921-rgiii/


but in summary..  overhyped undersized qb who probably should have position switched, fails to read defenses or put in effort to develop as a pocket passer.  instead of scrambling to buy time to throw scrambles to run and avoids sliding takes unnecessary hits constantly.  Thinks being a pocket passer means standing like a statue in the pocket instead of slight movements to the side to avoid rush.  Wildly inaccurate when not throwing the 3 passes that made everyone believe he was a superstar his rookie year (Slant, wr screen, and Go).   


Good armor, good athleticism, bad decision making, bad pocket movement

---