Quote:But i think you just offered a great reason for blowing it up. If he's making questionable personnel moves (trading monroe and drafting joeckel, not bringing daryl smith and knighton back), wouldnt keeping him around just result in more damage down the road? Idk that we've seem enough "hits" in terms of draft picks. His record hasnt been stellar in that regard, and his free agent signings have been OK at best.

I'm willing to wait another offseason with Caldwell but you won't catch me crying if he's gone at the season end. I'm hoping it all magically comes together but honestly I think caldwell could end up being worse than gene smith. When I say I don't advocate blowing it up I'm referring to the roster. If we do have a new GM/coach I want them to keep some of the young talent instead of gutting this roster like Caldwell did.


Gutting a roster never works it takes to long and requires a perfect draft strategy solid free agents good development and a little luck.

---