So... you posted this thought in one thread and then created a new thread?

Almost immediately.

And you people wonder why threads get deleted....

 

Well here are my thoughts, on topic.

Caldwell isn't perfect, but I dare you to find a GM that has made every right move all the time. I don't think it is time to move on from him. I don't think Chris Polian can take the credit and Caldwell gets none. And I'm pretty sure clot fans were glad the little Polian was gone and many Jags fans weren't ecstatic about the hire when it happened.

 

Now... throwing the Gus Bus over the edge isn't enough.... you want to get rid of the guy who is the only one in the past.... decade to give us talent, actual talent at the QB and WR position... seemingly replaced MJD well enough (after a couple fa tries) with Yeldon.

Essentially building an awesome core of offense for the foreseeable future. (Coupled with some very good young linemen and hopefully a TE threat, if he can stay healthy)

 

He also brought a defense out of the dumps, and while they aren't great, we went from bottom third to top third in sacks.

Also... aside from maybe having a superstar pick (we'll see with Fowler) this defense has improved even when we thought it'd be crap.

 

He did all this after gutting a roster and starting from scratch.

And after 3 years because of a perceived notion that his coach can't seem to get his young players to settle in, you want to get rid of the GM as well?

 

And start over, again?

 

And you think Chris Polian is the man for the job?

 

---