Quote:That "once-in-a-generation" talent is also coming into the league strapped with offseason surgery and a crappy motor. Caldwell is pretty clearly taking a quarterback in the first round at this point, so this debate is pointless. Bridgewater vs. Mariota is the only one that matters if Jacksonville secures the No. 1 pick.

those are minor concerns 

 

Quote:Honest question HeeRo,

 

It is absolute fact that a GM's destiny with a team is intertwined with the first QB they draft/sign/trade for. Do you honestly, HONESTLY think Dave Caldwell in his first job as a GM ever, is going to pass on a highly rated QB prospect that is considered to be very polished and NFL ready, for a Defensive End?

 

its the best player in the draft vs the top rated qb and we have dire need in both position so yes brandon its still a debate.  it all depends on how he values teddy and clowney tbh, he could see it your way or mine.  if he values clowney like i do its a hard decision to pass on either due to great de = good qb imo, if he values teddy more theres really no debate.

---