Quote:This had nothing to do with Gabbert but thanks for bringing his crappyness into this.

 

To think that this team wouldn't be better with Manning at QB is ridiculous. He would win us the raiders, rams, Broncos (they wouldnt have him), chargers, Titans, Cards Browns and Bills... Thats 8 wins... Not to mention he would give our defense a rest every once in a while.

 

The team might have a better record, but that's not the issue, the question is would Manning succeed on a team like this or fail. Like I said, we've seen how he plays under consistent pressure.

 

I consider someone of his caliber failing to make the playoffs to be failure, but maybe you consider not making the playoffs to be success.

 

A team like the Jaguars would drag him down to the point where weirdos on a message board would be touting that at least the Jaguars managed to beat some bottom feeders, and I wouldn't be sure about the Jaguars winning against all of those teams, either.

---