Quote:"

 

And I would still take Gene Smith (if I own a team) over any one of the posters ever posting on these boards.

Because as "educated" as any of us think we are by watching whatever "tape" we can find and listening to all the ex-players jargon on ESPN... we still know just a smidge of what it would take to actually be a GM.

 

Unless posters on here have ACTUALLY worked in scouting departments before.

 

Without that, no one opinion really should hold any more water than the other here.

But when you build up a reputation with your posts... it follows throughout all of your opinions. Good bad and everything else.