Quote:Not arguing that. He could very well develop into a Hall of Famer if he keeps it up. He very well could pile up 80+ catch 1200+ yard receiving seasons. If he does, he WILL be the greatest receiver in franchise history. Or he could fall back to earth next season as Blake spreads the ball around to Hurns/Lee/Thomas more cutting into his catches and yardage and Yeldon develops into a better red zone runner cutting into his TDs. According to this, 12 of his 14 TDS came inside the red zone. Can he keep the pace up?



http://nflsavant.com/targets.php?week=&d...lPosition=

 

Ok now we are starting to see eye to eye. If you look back, I never said I think Allen Robinson is better than Jimmy Smith is right now. My initial disagreement in this thread came when someone said "No there isn't [a debate to be had if ARob keeps this up]. There's one thing ARob does better than JSmooth...and that's high point a ball."

 

That isn't being fair to ARob who does some things, like uses his body and catch radius, remarkably well.

 

Can he keep up 14 TDs per year? I doubt it. Does he have the physical tools to be a better red zone target that Jimmy Smith was? I think so. Jimmy was elite. No argument from me there. I just think that Robinson has shown he has the tools to also be elite albeit with a different skillset than Jimmy had.

---