Quote:I don't think so, I believe his reputation exceeded his output. Really good player, but never fulfilled all that potential. Based on his retirement I think it speaks to his desire or lack thereof to be truly great.

 

My take is Calvin Johnson has given the Lions everything he's had over the years.   But his pain level has reached the point that even if Calvin ends up playing another season or two,  his body is telling him that it's not feasible to play well into his 30's.   If this truly the end of Calvin Johnson's playing career,   I don't think he should have any regrets in terms of effort and commitment. 

 

Because Calvin Johnson's impact and presence led the vast majority of teams to change their coverages to account for him,   combined with the stats and plays he made,  I would be very surprised if Calvin isn't in the HOF within a few seasons after he's eligible. 

---