You seem fixated on urges and desires and are all over the map. First you say trans people are doing it by choice (for attention -- mostly). And you have a hard time accepting the Drano lady has a mental disorder, even though it's stated in the title of the article you linked to. NOW you say you don't reject the biological explanation. Great!


You didn't even remotely answer the direct questions on XXY or XYY babies though. How would anyone know at the time of birth? I'm not talking about hermaphrodites as you allude to or any other deformities (like people with XY chromosomes, but eventually have breasts and/or lady parts). And more importantly, how would an XXY or XYY baby eventually realize they are not XX or XY?


If you do not reject the biological explanation, then does that mean you accept that there is the possibility these people are born this way, without a choice? Some people come to self-realization they are trans around the age they start becoming aware of their sexuality. Others like Jazz Jennings and my friend's daughter came to the self-realization in early childhood.


I will use these young people as a perfect example. Both raised in good homes, they self identified as trans before an age where sexual urges could have possibly developed. In neither case was there any sort of influence to be trans. Since now you confess to being open to the biological explanation, how can you reject the very real possibility these people were in fact born that way?

---