Quote:Last two times I am jumping in here for real (the other for jagsgooner next), since you all really don't get it.


1. Hurns didn't have 1100+ and 10 TDs last year either, and even if he did who cares? 1100 and 10 are some random arbitrary benchmark numbers that you completely made up, it is not some magical qualifying number to make it onto any lists. And just because someone in the past did or didn't have those numbers and did or didn't make the list in X year, it doesn't mean someone putting up similar numbers the next year deserves to make it. Every one of these is a logical fallacy.


2. By the most optimistic measure I can find Hurns was the 16th best WR (or 12th per snap), that's really good and if 12 was more or less a consensus then he would probably deserve a spot on the back end of a top 100 probably. But it's the outlier of the metrics not the consensus. By most metrics he was around 20-24 last year, again really good, but not a top 100 player.


3. I could be wrong, and in no way am I going to take the time to look it up and/or wait for the results of the rest of the top 100 and come back, but I will guess that guys like Joe Berger and Weston Richburg probably don't make the top 100. Nor do I think guys like Rodney McLeod or George Iloka will. Those were probably the top 2 centers and two of the top 6 safeties in the league last year. Hopefully I'm wrong and all 4 make it because they very much deserve it, but my point is people are going to have excellent seasons and be left off a top 100 list for many reasons. Hurns doesn't deserve to make it over any of those 4, or a multitude of others that will wind up not making it.