Quote:The two rookie seasons rosters aren't even comparable. 

get outta here with that.

 

Bortles rookie season was a roster full of rookies.

Luck had all sorts of vets.

Also believe it or not, the clots D was better than the Jaguars D.

 

Also... no one is saying that Luck wasn't the better QB coming out of college. But NOW...

Luck has regressed, and wasn't playing well last season.

 

But....carry on.

Aside from Reggie Wayne and Robert Mathis, name the roster full of veterans? Luck played with T.Y. Hilton, Whalen, Brazill, Fleener, D.Allen, and Vick Ballard -- all rookies on offense. I'm sorry but there are more similarities between the two teams, (which had to rebuild) than you are giving credit for. 

 

I do agree that the Colts defense was better than the Jaguars defense, but it was not a good defense. Average would be a good description at moments. Below average is far more suitable.

 

The post that I responded to mentioned that Luck had been mediocre to bad, to which I responded that he had the best 3-year start of any QB in history, as far as passing yards are concerned. He also had a great start as far as wins and TDs are concerned. Yes, the INTs are an issue, but he still compensates that by winning.

 

Luck has improved every year he has been in the league, with the exception of the one year that he was injured (last year). You are going to base your analysis that he regressed on 1 year -- the only year he was injured -- and ignore the other three years? Is that an intellectually honest approach?

---