Carr over Manziel for me easily. Im not fully sold on Carr as i feel Bridgewater is still better but Carr does have the potential and im warming up to him as i wacth game after game on draft breakdown.

 

Carr really does have the best deep ball of the class and his short/medium range touch is nearly on Bridgewaters level. I feel Teddy to be the more cerebral Qb while Carr is the more classic gunslinger think with my arm(gun) type of QB. Neither are truly scramblers but both can take off with Bridgewater to me seeming to be slightly faster but slightly more likely to take a big hit due to a smaller frame.

 

Carr is closing the gap and at this point its starting to be which one better fits your team vs which one is actually better. If we can work on Carr's footwork and ability to  makes reads/checks at the line than i have no problem with taking him.

---