Of course Caldwell deserves criticism. No one should be safe if we finish with another 5 or less win season. However, Caldwell is the best GM this franchise has ever had. He has a great eye for talent. Caldwell just didn't pick a good coach, which is understandable for a at-the-time rookie GM. No good, experienced coaches would have taken over THAT roster that Gene Smith left us with. If Gus gets fired, Caldwell would be the reason we are able to attain a good coach... he has this roster loaded with young talent. Gus is just not a good developer of talent, and he doesn't know how to adjust his scheme to put the best players on the field. I thought we might have had the horses to run this stupid scheme, but ultimately, the coaches need to adjust to the talent they have. Stop forcing the damn scheme when it ain't working!

---