Quote:lol yeah because we needed a qb early in the 08 draft.... almost all QBs taken in the first round are overdrafted and especially the #1 overall pick. i just want the best player in the draft and that right now is clowney.

I don't get your point at all. We needed a good player, we got a complete bust. You compared a bad QB to a good DE, I just did the opposite to point out why that comparison makes no sense. The only fair way to do it is to compare two good players at different positions, otherwise you aren't comparing positions at all, you're just comparing a bad player to a good one and position becomes irrelevant then.


When you do compare two similar level players, the QB clearly wins.

---