Quote:I don't recall anyone saying it wasn't a TD.  The debate is whether the refs where right to not overturn it.  If you go by the letter of the rule book, you need indisputable proof on the replay that the call should be overturned before it can be overturned.  The refs have made plenty of mistakes against us this year, but that wasn't one.

 

Nobody said it was not a TD. It was all about the inability to see indisputable visual evidence unless you are looking at a frozen frame on CBS. Because referees now get help from Manhattan I think it was ridiculous that only people watching the game at home saw it. If the referee or anybody at the NFL headquarters is allowed to freeze it, why didn't they do that?

---