Quote: (I personally dont see punters as a key signing)

 

I included him because he has actually made an impact in a few games  - and by comparison Gene took one way too early in the draft that made very little to zero impact in 4 years. 

 

Comparing the way the two GMs chose to address need at the position - the wiser GM is clear. 

 

I agree with your points on Amukamara and Ivory to some degree, but they were meant to be compared to what Gene did at their positions  -- I wasn't touting them as elite talent.  Just better talent at their position than Gene was able to acquire. 

 

(I do expect we'll see Ivory's production trend well upward with Hackett running the offense however.)

---