Not gonna vote because I'm not invested either way. Caldwell has been mediocre and this is his first stint as a GM. You would expect him to have learned from his mistakes going forward and to become better than mediocre, but there's no guarantee with that or anything else. Our previous two GMs were less than mediocre in my opinion. My concern in letting Caldwell go is that you potentially bring in another sub-mediocre GM to replace him, but I'll lose no sleep over it if he is indeed let go at the end of the season. You have to already have the guy lined up and ready to accept the job if you let Caldwell go. Otherwise let it ride another year.

---