Quote:Seth Payne?

 

Alualu has been more productive and a more consistent producer than Payne and that production was accomplished in 3 less seasons than Payne.

 

If Tyson were paying on the jaguar teams back in their heyday, people wouldn't be having this conversation. everyone would be fondly remembering him too. It's easy to exaggerate someone's weaknesses when their career was spent on bad teams.

 

A more productive guy is trash and a less productive guy is fondly remembered. Just goes to show you the double standard people set in their mind based solely on draft position.

Yes, Seth Payne.

 

His first couple of years, Payne struggled mightily.

 

However, by 2000, he and Walker were a formidable DT duo. His play helped keep Stroud on the bench in Stroud's rookie year in 2001.

 

I disagree about the whole heyday argument.

 

I do not view Renaldo Wynn favorably at all, and he was on the Jaguars best ever team.  I view him and Alualu about the same.

 

Both were just guys. 

 

Chris Hudson was also on the team in the heyday.  I would take Gipson over him every single time.

---