Quote:So you don't think Luck is that good?? I think Luck is very good and will only get better as he gets more experience. He got drafted by a 2-14 team and took them to the playoffs in his 1st year and is going again in his 2nd year, that's pretty darn good to me.

 

Is he elite?? Well that depends on your definition of elite. While I consider him very very good, I don't consider him elite yet, although of all the QB's taken in the last several drafts I consider Luck with the most potential to become an elite QB.

 

Is he Peyton Manning back there?? NO, but then again, there is only one PM. I'm glad he isn't PM, because that guy just owned the division.

 

I have a question for you if you don't think he's anything special. Would you take him on the Jags??

 

I just spent the majority of my post saying that luck is good.  But he's not elite.  He needs players around him to excel.  If he doesn't, he's an Eli or Romo type QB.  He'll get you points in fantasy, but he's not gonna get you a SB unless the rest of the team around him is also good.  

 

And compared to who we have at QB right now, of course I would take Luck.  I would also take Eli, Romo, Rivers, Alex Smith, Wilson, Kapernick, and a bunch of other good QB's over who we have behind center right now.  

 

That's not the point.  The point is that the caveman is beatable.  He's good, but he's not elite.  We shouldn't fear good QB's, unless the rest of the team that is around the QB is also very good.  Otherwise, we can continue this rebuild and be contenders.  We just need a good QB or our own...

---