(08-09-2017, 01:22 PM)copycat Wrote:

(08-09-2017, 12:16 PM)Kane Wrote: So all the stuff I listed... sweep sweep?

I am not denying had some spectacular seasons, he also had some bad ones.  My personal opinion is I would not put him in the HoF due to up and down seasons.  Consider that he was let go by a team he took to two Super Bowls winning one of them.   Yes he bounced back Kudos to him.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 That is not taking anything away from him.  There are a lot of fantastic players that are not in the HoF.

I'm flabbergasted.
Like I said... his "bad" years with the Rams were due to a broken hand/finger issue that lingered. Kinda important for a QB.
His one season with the G-Men he was their stop gap for Eli, but I think he could have made noise if given the opportunity but we'll never know. Statistically, he wasn't terrible in NY.
Then he went to AZ and after some waffling by coaches they finally gave Warner control and he had great seasons with them.

I'm not saying he's the best QB ever.. but well deserving to be in the HoF
It wasn't like he was a first ballot guy or nothin.... they made him wait for Favre and some others.

I suppose you're entitled to your opinion as I am mine...
even if not this year, I don't see how you leave this guy out of the HoF

---