(07-25-2019, 08:23 PM)JagFan81 Wrote:

(07-23-2019, 02:27 PM)Bullseye Wrote: I bet that if PI were reviewable two years ago, they wouldn't have reversed either PI against us in the AFCCG.

Well 

1. Myles Jack wasn't down.
2. Hell no would they have called that in the 4th in Foxboro.

I just fear it's going to open a lot of problems. The Robey-Coleman call was awful, but he committed like 4 fouls, the ref swallowing his whistle was the problem. 

But what happens say. Hopkins against Jalen. Now they review if there was PA against Jalen. But in review, before the DPA, Hopkins commits PA. Do you ignore that? Does that override Jalens PA? 

I just fear they've added even more grey areas when we had plenty already (what the hell is a catch, roughing the passer, fumbles etc)

I don't see the issue.  It's not like the coaches get any more challenges.  If they want to take a chance on a challenge of a non-call PI, so be it.  

Hell, to me, they [BLEEP] up calls even with review.  I think they should do away with (or never should have had) the whole thing.  If players make mistakes, why aren't refs permitted to.

---