If you want a good career backup, yea he would be a nice pick, if you want a franchise QB then no

This is a very unpopular (albeit correct) opinion around here haha. 

---

Carr Teddy Garropolo or Mettenberger in the 2nd.


Murray in the 4th.


We all set!

---

I think he's ONE of the guys. He'll be the 2nd QB taken by the Jags.

 

I think I would rather have Logan Thomas at that spot.   Tremendous potential, but a lot of development work to do.   Murray is a finished product, I don't see that much upside.   If we invest a 5th round pick in a QB, and it's the second QB we draft this year, I want a guy with a very high upside. 

---

I think I would rather have Logan Thomas at that spot.   Tremendous potential, but a lot of development work to do.   Murray is a finished product, I don't see that much upside.   If we invest a 5th round pick in a QB, and it's the second QB we draft this year, I want a guy with a very high upside. 

Are you willing to take Logan at 39 though...cause he's most likely gonna be gone by our 3rd round pick.

---

Are you willing to take Logan at 39 though...cause he's most likely gonna be gone by our 3rd round pick.

 

No, I would not take Logan Thomas before the late 4th round.   He would sit on the bench for probably two years, and I think we can still get guys in the 4th round who would get on the field and contribute.

---

No, I would not take Logan Thomas before the late 4th round.   He would sit on the bench for probably two years, and I think we can still get guys in the 4th round who would get on the field and contribute.

Yeah I agree. I would love him as a dev QB pick on day 3...but I really think he'll be long gone by then. 

---

Carr Teddy Garropolo or Mettenberger in the 2nd.


Murray in the 4th.


We all set!

Had a nightmare last night(no lie) that we drafted Garropolo with the third pick

---

I really hope we grab him. I don't see him lasting past the fourth. Jon Gruden loved him while he was at qb camp, calling him the steal of the draft.

---

I really hope we grab him. I don't see him lasting past the fourth. Jon Gruden loved him while he was at qb camp, calling him the steal of the draft.

To be fair Gruden loves everyone

---

To be fair Gruden loves everyone

 

Yep, on that show of his, he's never trashing any of the QB on it as a final grade. 

---

This is a very unpopular (albeit correct) opinion around here haha. 

 

Given the two of you, this speaks very well for Murray.

---

"You do your own thing in your own time. You should be proud."

If we don't take one in the first, I'd be quite alright with waiting til the 4th or so for Murray. Don't think he'll ever be great, but I think he can be pretty good.

---

- Just over 6 foot 1. Similar to Wilson/Brees in his measurables .

 

- We have 11 picks. Two 4ths and three 5ths. Right where Murray is projected to be drafted. Allows the Jags to fill other needs before he's off the board.

 

- Georgia boy. Caldwell came from Atlanta where he's been privy to Aaron's play.

 

- Competitive drive. Coming back from an ACL and being determined to make an NFL career is something Gus has gone on record saying he admires.

 

- Strong arm, ice in his veins, no fear of pressure, stands in the pocket strongly.

 

- Gus was the only HC at his pro day.

 

- He can scramble. Not to the extent of Manziel but effectively enough like Brees can cause a defense hassle.

 

- He will be able to sit and learn. We don't have to throw him into the fire. Caldwell says a lot of rookies had to start and this year will be different. Perfect for Murray coming off an injury.

 

- #11. It's a sign. We got rid of Gabbert to give Murray his college number. Haha.

 

He's just over 6'0.  He's 6004.

 

Strong arm is laughable.  Slightly below average arm at best.

 

Ice in his veins?  He was terrible at crunch time against good teams.

---

Are you willing to take Logan at 39 though...cause he's most likely gonna be gone by our 3rd round pick.

What? On what planet is Logan Thomas a second-round pick?

---

What? On what planet is Logan Thomas a second-round pick?

 

Perhaps Earth, if Chip Kelly or Jim Harbaugh fall in love.

 

I wouldn't put it past their egos to believe they can do it.  Because to them, it's not about the player.  It's about the coach's "ability."

---

"You do your own thing in your own time. You should be proud."

Given the two of you, this speaks very well for Murray.

 

Are you saying that Murray can be a franchise guy?

---

He's just over 6'0.  He's 6004.

 

Strong arm is laughable.  Slightly below average arm at best.

 

Ice in his veins?  He was terrible at crunch time against good teams.

A below average arm cant make a lot of these passes, Murray is also probably the best deep ball thrower in this draft, and the best at using the pump fake.

 

http://youtu.be/piAUVTjOIgU

---

A below average arm cant make a lot of these passes, Murray is also probably the best deep ball thrower in this draft, and the best at using the pump fake.

I disagree with this part. I believe that distinction belongs to Carr.

---

"Before you criticize a man, walk a mile in his shoes. That way, if he gets angry, he's a mile away and barefoot."

I think that Murray's ceiling is Andy Dalton. Personally, while I wouldn't want to blow a first or second round pick on that while better players are available, I'd be pretty happy with him in four so long as we draft a QB with a higher ceiling before him.

---

A below average arm cant make a lot of these passes, Murray is also probably the best deep ball thrower in this draft, and the best at using the pump fake.

 

http://youtu.be/piAUVTjOIgU

 

You are serious?  Posting a highlight video... and it doesn't even highlight arm strength?

 

He threw no opposite hash deep outs or any other relevant NFL throw.  It was all deep downfield.  And... Only 1 pass in that video traveled over 45-50 yards in the air.  

 

Supposedly Tim Tebow is the posterboy for weak arms, although I'd consider it average with poor accuracy.  

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aLLBKPDT9FU

 

Even Tebow can throw 65 yards in the air.

---