Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Was just wondering if we pick at 3 and Teddy and Clowney are off the board and Dave decides he wants to go pass rusher with his 1st round pick, who would you rather us draft? 

Mack or Barr?

Yes

Mack is a great prospect, but he has been greatly overhyped. Unless we trade down, I don't want to take him in the first round. We're he to drop to the 2nd though, it would be a no brainer.


http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap2000000...-nfl-draft

Quote:Mack is a great prospect, but he has been greatly overhyped. Unless we trade down, I don't want to take him in the first round. We're he to drop to the 2nd though, it would be a no brainer.

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap2000000...-nfl-draft

That is just Bucky Brooks take.  Mack is a beast! Dude is a great pass rusher, all time leader in NCAA in FF, and is built like Patrick Willis.  I think alot will depend on his 40 time.

 

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap2000000...von-miller

 

http://espn.go.com/nfl/draft

Give me either. I don't care about Macks 40 or any workout numbers unless they're alarmingly bad. I've seen him play a few times he'll do just fine on the nfl level

I like both a lot. I think Mack is a bit more physical and polished but Barr has a higher ceiling with his speed, agility, and having produced those numbers in only two seasons since being converted from a RB

Mack has a little Demarcus Ware in him.

Mack will go top5 easily. You really can't lose with either prospect.

Mack is a good player. Not sure I see a guy I would take in the top 5.

Quote:Mack is a good player. Not sure I see a guy I would take in the top 5.

 

what about Barr?

Quote:Give me either. I don't care about Macks 40 or any workout numbers unless they're alarmingly bad. I've seen him play a few times he'll do just fine on the nfl level

Like Jarvis Jones

Quote:what about Barr?

 

Barr probably has the higher ceiling but I see him as a Dion Jordan. I don't think you can expect much from him as a rookie. 

 

Clowney is so far ahead of both of them, it isn't funny.

Quote:Barr probably has the higher ceiling but I see him as a Dion Jordan. I don't think you can expect much from him as a rookie. 

 

Clowney is so far ahead of both of them, it isn't funny.

 

I do agree that Clowney is def ahead of them. 

 

If we get pick 2, then we really can't lose. Guaranteed one of Bridgewater or Clowny. 

I wonder how they fit in Bradley's system.

Quote:I wonder how they fit in Bradley's system.

 

Good coaches fit systems around talent, not vice versa. 

Quote:Mack has a little Demarcus Ware in him.

Mack has a whole lot of Ware in him. Easiest straight up comp in this draft IMO. 

Quote:Mack has a little Demarcus Ware in him.

 

...Sounds painful.

Quote:Good coaches fit systems around talent, not vice versa. 

 

That's not what he and Carroll did in Seattle.

Quote:Mack has a whole lot of Ware in him. 

 

Even worse!

Quote:That's not what he and Carroll did in Seattle.

 

Lets not annoint he & Carroll until they actually win something. Carroll has yet to even reach a SB let alone win one.